It was a moment that 14-year-old
Meaghan O'Connor of Dover, N.H., says may stay with
her for the rest of her life.
She was charging for the ball in
the midst of a heated basketball game last summer.
Suddenly, another girl's knee smashed into hers.
``I fell to the floor,'' recalls
O'Connor. Right away, ``it got all swollen. I was
crying.''
Her parents took her home and put
ice on her knee, and at first that seemed to do the
trick. But a week later, she tried to play again.
Her knee really hurt, she recalls. Perhaps even more
ominous, it kept buckling as she played.
Her parents took her to one
doctor, then another. The diagnosis? A torn ACL, or
anterior cruciate ligament, the most common severe
joint injury in sports today, and a particular
plague for vigorous young women like O'Connor.
A generation ago, it was rare to
see a healthy young woman limping in to see her
doctor with a knee wrecked in friendly combat on
high school or college playing fields.
Today, a knee freshly bandaged
from surgery or a high-tech knee brace has become a
sign of the times for young female jocks, the kind
of dubious honor that shows both how far women have
come in crashing the barriers to full participation
in sports -- and the price some are paying for their
shot at athletic glory.
In 1982-83, for instance, there
were 80,000 female athletes competing in college
sports, according to the National Collegiate
Athletic Association. By 1994-1995, the figure had
swelled to 110,500, with a 9 percent increase in
1989 to 1992 alone, the NCAA says.
In high school sports, the figures
are even more dramatic. In 1971, before the federal
law known as Title IX mandated that girls and boys
get comparable athletic opportunities, fewer than
300,000 girls participated, according to the
National Federation of State High School
Associations.
A year later, thanks to Title IX,
the number had soard to more than 800,000. Today,
there are 2.4 million.
The downside of all this forward
motion, sad to say, is that men and women now have a
chance to injure themselves at roughly similar rates
in many sports.
But certain sports, especially
those like soccer and basketball that demand a lot
of pivoting and fast changes of speed and direction,
seem to take a higher toll on women than on men.
Especially on the anterior
cruciate ligament in the knee.
In one recent study, Dr. Elizabeth
Arendt, medical director of men's and women's
varsity athletics at the University of Minnesota,
and Randall Dick, associate director of sports
sciences at the NCAA, documented striking gender
differences in ACL injuries in soccer and
basketball, sports in which the rules are comparable
for men and women.
Overall, they found, the rate of
the injury during the five-year study was three to
four times higher among females than males. In
basketball, women were three times more likely to
rip their ACLs; in soccer, twice as likely. Most of
the damage was from non-contact, twisting injuries.
``It's peculiar why this shows a
gender or sex difference,'' says Arendt. In fact,
``It's rather alarming that we don't know the
answer, but we don't know it for men, either.''
Part of the reason the anterior
cruciate ligament takes such a beating is that
evolution hasn't yet come up with a better solution
for a joint that must be both flexible and capable
of carrying tremendous weight.
This means that you may be asking
for knee trouble if you play hard, both in contact
sports like football and some non-contact sports
like skiing. In skiing, modern technology -- in the
form of boots that lock the leg in a forward
position -- actually makes things worse by making
the ligament vulnerable to rips if you fall over
backwards.
But for growing numbers of young
female basketball and soccer players -- and for many
researchers -- the most pressing question is why the
risk of the ligament injury is especially acute for
women.
One theory is that women's wider
hips cause the femur, or thigh bone, to come into
the knee at a broader angle. Men's hips, knees and
feet usually line up straight, says Nicholas
Giurleo, director of physical therapy at Concord
Avenue Physical Therapy Associates in Cambridge.
But in women, he says, wider hips
may make the knees slightly ``knocked'' or tilted
inward, which can make the joints more vulnerable.
Wider hips may also explain why
women's kneecaps slide around too much side to side,
adds Lori Thein Brody, a physical therapist at the
University of Wisconsin in Madison.
Another theory is that women and
men may have a different balance between the
quadriceps muscle on the front of the thigh and the
hamstrings at the back.
In general, men have bulkier
muscles because they have higher levels of male
hormones, but even in women with impressive quads,
the hamstrings may be relatively weak. Because the
hamstrings work with the ligament to stabilize the
knee, if they are weak or underused, the knee may be
in jeopardy.
Women are also more loose-jointed
than men because female hormones make some ligaments
stretch, a decided benefit during childbirth but a
risk if knees are too loose.
Regardless of why women's knees
are more vulnerable, once the ligament is damaged,
the best treatment is to let the knee heal for four
to six weeks so that the joint regains its range of
motion, then to operate, says Dr. Bertram Zarins,
chief of sports medicine at Massachusetts General
Hospital.
In surgery to reconstruct torn
anterior cruciate ligaments, which is performed more
than 10,000 times a year and is considered 90 to 95
percent successful -- the repairs are usually made
through small viewing tubes called arthroscopes
inserted into the knee.
In addition, doctors often make a
two-to-three-inch incision to ``harvest'' a small
piece of the kneecap tendon to replace the damaged
ligament.
In the procedure, doctors snip off
the dangling ends of the damaged ligament, then take
a third of the tendon that anchors the kneecap --
with small pieces of bone still attached at either
end -- and screw it into tunnels made in the ends of
the thigh bone and the tibia, where the ligament was
anchored.
The graft ``is almost the same
size as the ACL and is the same strength,'' says
Zarins, adding that the tendon from which it was
taken regrows and regains its original strength.
Though most reconstructive surgery uses this
technique, some Boston surgeons use a piece of the
hamstring instead of the patellar tendon.
Like Meaghan O'Connor, some
patients who have this surgery spend 23 hours a day
for a week with the knee in a continuous passive
motion machine to keep it from freezing up as it
heals.
The encouraging news, say
orthopedic specialists, is that while recovery from
ACL surgery used to take a year, accelerated
rehabilitation programs now allow athletes to return
to sports in about six months.
Even that, of course, is a long
time in the life of a healthy young athlete like
O'Connor, who has been chafing at the bit since her
surgery in August.
She plans to run track this spring
to get in shape for basketball next summer. For her,
as for many young female athletes, the joy of sports
is well worth the risk.
In fact, when her doctor told her
that the only way to make sure she didn't re-injure
her knee was to quit basketball, she had her answer
all ready: ``I didn't want to do that.''
SIDEBAR 1:
REPAIRING A TORN ANTERIOR CRUCIATE
LIGAMENT
PLEASE SEE MICROFILM FOR CHART
DATA
GLOBE STAFF GRAPHIC/DAVID BUTLER
SIDEBAR 2:
Some tips to avoid
injury
If you're serious about a sport --
and equally serious about not wrecking your knees --
there are several things you can do, say physical
therapists and doctors who specialize in sports
medicine.
While many of these tips can help
athletes avoid knee injuries in general, they are
designed for female athletes who want to avoid
injury to the ACL, or anterior cruciate ligament.
- Coaching. Get a good coach as
soon as you start doing any sport seriously.
Parents don't count, unless they're trained as
coaches. Ask your coach, nicely, what
credentials and training she or he has had.
- Skill level. Play with people
at your level. In basketball, if you play with
klutzes below your level, they may make up for
their lack of skills with brute force. And if
they can't move as fast as you, you may end up
tripping over them. On the other hand, if you're
the klutz, you may twist yourself into
knee-wrecking contortions to keep up.
- Fatigue and pain. Don't play
when you're exhausted and don't play through
real pain. Among other things, this means
distinguishing between ``I'm sick of this and I
want to go home'' feelings and the sharp,
stabbing pain of genuine injury, a pain that
comes back as soon as you start playing again.
- Shoes. It's common sense to
wear shoes with good arch support and
shock-absorbing capacity -- in sports as well as
the rest of your life. But studies are mixed on
whether shoes can be blamed for women's ACL
injuries. If your shoes are too ``good,'' that
is, give you too much traction, your foot won't
give way on fast stops, and the resulting torque
on your knee can rip the ligament.
- Posture. For many women, the
``default posture'' -- how you stand when you're
not thinking about it -- is with the knees
hyperextended or arched slightly backward. Some
researchers think that if you habitually stand
this way, you may land wrong on jumps, too.
- Landings. Many ACL injuries
could be prevented if athletes were taught to
land correctly from jumps -- with knees bent,
not hyperextended, and with feet under the hips.
Landing on bent knees gives the hamstrings a
chance to stabilize the knee.
- Fast stops, cuts and turns.
When you have to decelerate and change direction
fast, take three small ``stutter steps'' instead
of one big one. When this three-step stop was
taught to two major women's basketball teams,
the incidence of ACL injuries dropped 89 percent
over several years.
- Weights. Get to the weight
room. Take the time -- three sessions a week --
to build up your leg muscles, especially your
hamstrings. Try to work with a trainer certified
by a recognized organization such as the
National Strength and Conditioning Association.
If you think you're headed for trouble, get a
physical therapist to check you for any
abnormalities in your gait and imbalances
between muscle groups.
- Warm-ups. Never start jumping
and pivoting hard unless you're thoroughly
warmed up, i.e., actually sweating.
- Stick with the sport you love
-- sensibly. It may make sense to switch sports
if you think the one you've chosen is too risky.
But don't let the naysayers get you down too
easily.
Decades ago, when women first
started competing in long distance running events,
half fainted at the finish, prompting the
International Olympic Committee to conclude that
women were too delicate for the tough stuff, says
Dr. Elizabeth Arendt, medical director of men's and
women's varsity athletics at the University of
Minnesota.
That's a ``Neanderthal'' attitude,
she says. Life is inherently risky, and "people play
a sport because they love it."